Is your refrigerator acting up? If it's running too warm, leaking water, or making strange noises, you might have a problem with it. It's easy to feel stuck between two choices: repair or replace refrigerator units. But like many homeowners feel sometimes, the right answer isn't always obvious.
A simple repair can often bring your fridge back to life, usually at less cost than buying new. But on the other hand, replacing an outdated or inefficient unit entirely can save you money on the repair costs and energy bills, while sparing you from future breakdowns.
Before you decide to repair or replace refrigerator, use our guide that walks you through five vital questions to help weigh your options. From considering the age of your appliance to reviewing your budget, read this first before you call a technician or buy a new one.
Discover Refrigerator Deals
Explore a full selection of reliable refrigerators at Don's Appliances
Shop RefrigeratorsRepair or Replace Refrigerator? | 5 Questions to Ask
The uncertainty between refrigerator repair vs replace is a common question among homeowners. Repair might be quick and affordable, but a replacement could offer better reliability. For the smartest decision between repair vs replace refrigerator, let's ask five questions before deciding.
How Old Is Your Refrigerator?
Your refrigerator's age is the first thing you should review when problems start to appear and you start to consider whether to repair or replace refrigerator units. Like any appliance, a fridge doesn't last forever and sometimes replacing it makes more sense. In many cases, age alone can be the deciding factor, especially if the fridge is already inefficient or frequently breaking down.
So, is it worth repairing a refrigerator? Most refrigerators have an average lifespan of 10 to 15 years, but refrigerator longevity depends on the brand, usage, and how well they've been maintained. If your fridge is older than 10 years old, replacing a refrigerator is often more economical in the long run.
On top of that, older refrigerator models are often more expensive to repair, especially when certain refrigerator parts are longer available. It's also not rare for common components like compressor, condenser coils, fan motors, and door seals to wear out as the appliances age. Once these major parts begin failing, repair costs can add up or offer only a temporary fix. That's when you know when to replace a fridge.
What Refrigerator Problems Are You Dealing With?
Not all fridge issues are created equal. Some common refrigerator problems are quick and affordable to fix, while others can signal bigger trouble. Understanding what's wrong can help you decide whether to repair or replace refrigerator (CLICK THE ➕ TO LEARN MORE).
➕Bad Refrigerator Compressor
The compressor is the heart of a refrigerator. If it fails, a fridge won't cool properly. Unfortunately, replacing a refrigerator compressor can be expensive, and on older units, it often makes more sense to replace the whole appliance.
➕Worn-Out Door Seal (Gasket)
A cracked or loose refrigerator door gasket lets cold air escape, forcing the fridge to work harder. Fortunately, this is an easy and low-cost repair that can quickly improve efficiency.
➕Broken Refrigerator Motor
If a fridge evaporator or condenser fan motor goes out, the entire unit may stop cooling evenly. Motor replacements are typically mid-range in cost but may be worth it if a refrigerator is still relatively new, and in some cases, a warranty on a new refrigerator can help cover the costs.
➕Refrigerator Not Cooling
Poor cooling could stem from several problems, including clogged coils, low refrigerant, or a failing thermostat. The cost will depend on the cause and how severe it is.
➕Refrigerator Leaking Water
Leaks are often due to a blocked defrost drain or a cracked water line. These are usually minor fixes, but if the leak has caused hidden damage, the costs can climb.
➕Making Loud Noises
Unusual refrigerator sounds may point to a worn fan, a failing compressor, or loose parts. Some noise issues are minor, but persistent or worsening sounds may signal more serious trouble.
Does Your Refrigerator Have Enough Capacity?
If your household grows or your needs change, your current refrigerator might be struggling to keep up. On top of being an inconvenience, overstuffing your fridge can cause it to have poor air circulation or result in blocked vents and sensors. It also leads to spoiled food or increased energy use.
That’s all t say that if you constantly run out of fridge space, replacing your fridge could be a sensible upgrade. Buying a new refrigerator gives you the chance to increase storage capacity. Modern models have smarter layouts and bigger cubic feet, making it easier to store fresh foods, leftovers, and meal prep without straining the machine or its components.
Here’s a quick refrigerator capacity guide to how much space you should aim for:
- Households of 3: Around 16–18 cubic feet of fresh food storage is typically sufficient.
- Households of 4: Aim for at least 20–24 cubic feet to comfortably hold everyone’s groceries.
- Households of 5 or more: Look for 25 cubic feet or more, especially if you cook frequently or store bulk items.
Is Your Refrigerator the Right Size for Your Kitchen?
Just like capacity, refrigerator dimensions matters, especially in kitchens with tight layouts, narrow walkways, or limited clearance.
Even if your current refrigerator fits in its spot, it may not work well if it doesn't match your kitchen layout. If your fridge begins showing issues, consider changing it to the right size according to your kitchen's layout to improve the overall traffic flow, accessibility, and kitchen efficiency.
Here’s a quick breakdown of standard refrigerator widths and the types of kitchens they suit best:
- 30” Refrigerators: Refrigerators 30” wide are compact, making them ideal for smaller kitchens, apartments, or galley layouts.
- 33” Refrigerators: This fridge size is a great middle ground for average-sized kitchens and household. They provide more storage than a 30” model while still fitting comfortably in many standard cabinet openings.
- 36” Refrigerators: Refrigerators measuring 36” wide are the standard, offering plenty of room for the typical household. Consider a counter depth 36” refrigerator if space constraints are a concern. They won’t have as many cubic feet, but the wider layout is easier to organize while the shallow depth doesn’t obstruct kitchen workflow.
What's Your Budget?
Budget always has the biggest role in deciding whether to repair or replace refrigerator. Yes, the cost for repairing a refrigerator can sometimes seem cheaper upfront, but it might end up accumulating more over time (especially if problems keep coming back), and this will undoubtedly strain your household budget.
Of course, repairs can range widely in cost depending on the issue. But homeowners may spend several hundred dollars or more fixing major components like compressors or motors. If your fridge is older or has had multiple repairs already, the total expense might approach or even exceed the price of a new, energy-efficient model.
If you do decide to repair, trusting the right experts will matter. Repair services by trustworthy sources like Don's Appliances, which specialize in handling all types of refrigerators—including luxury brands like Sub-Zero, Viking, and Thermador—will give you a solid repair experience. Our services come from skilled technicians to ensure the quality and reliable fixes that help extend the life of your appliances.
Learn More: How to Fix a Refrigerator: Is the Cost Worth it?
Breaking Down Refrigerator Repair Costs
Understanding the typical repair costs for common fridge issues will help you weigh your options when deciding when to buy a new refrigerator or repair it. As mentioned, some repairs may be fairly affordable, while others can quickly add up.
Factors like gaskets or motors may have repeat issues, so even if their repairs are affordable, costs can accumulate over time. However, if your fridge is older than 10 years old and, for example, the compressor is broken, it's usually much more straightforward to buy a replacement than keep paying for ineffective repairs.
To draw an idea of what the costs are, check out these rough average repair costs for common problems with refrigerators:
- Average cost to repair refrigerator compressor: $400 to $1,200
- Average cost to repair a refrigerator seal (gasket): $100 to $200
- Average cost to repair a broken refrigerator motor: $200 to $400
- Average cost to repair refrigerator cooling: $150 to $600
- Average cost to repair a leaking refrigerator: $100 to $300
- Average cost to repair a noisy refrigerator: $150 to $500
If budget is a concern, remember to consider buying a new refrigerator flexible financing options to spread payments out rather than paying the full price upfront. This makes upgrading more manageable and sometimes even less costly in the short term than a major repair.
Explore Reliable Refrigerator Brands
Choosing the right refrigerator means picking a brand known for quality, durability, and features that fit your lifestyle. Here’s a look at some of the most trusted brands for when to replace refrigerator models.
Bosch Refrigerators
Known for sleek designs and energy efficiency, Bosch refrigerators deliver reliable performance with smart storage solutions perfect for modern kitchens.
Featured Pick: Bosch® 800 Series 36 in. 20.5 Cu. Ft. Stainless Steel Counter Depth French Door Refrigerator
The Bosch B36CL80SNS refrigerator delivers exceptional performance with its precise temperature control and quiet operation. The stainless steel design will look good in modern kitchens, while the spacious capacity with nearly 21 cubic feet of storage is ideal for standard households. It's also equipped with the innovative VitaFreshPro feature that maintains optimal humidity levels to keep fruits and veggies fresh for longer. Best of all, this model is energy-efficient, making it reliable for everyday use.
Maytag Refrigerators
Built tough and backed by a strong 10-year warranty, Maytag refrigerators are well-known in the industry for their durability and powerful cooling capabilities.
Featured Pick: Maytag® 36 in. 24.7 Cu. Ft. Fingerprint Resistant Stainless Steel French Door Refrigerator
Robust performance plus thoughtful design equals excellent function in the kitchen. That’s the standout advantage of this Maytag French Door refrigerator. Crafted with PowerCold feature for advanced freshness and a Wide-N-Fresh deli drawer offers customizable temperature settings to preserve deli meats and cheeses, it’s the perfect setup for food organization. And because Maytag is committed to durability, there's a 10-year limited parts warranty on the compressor—a great deal for a fantastic fridge.
⭐Featured Maytag MFI2570FEZ Review:
"Love the French door style. The space in the refrigerator is so much more useable than with my previous side-by-side model. Items are easy to see and reach, meaning less food waste."
Sub-Zero Refrigerators
This luxury brand is synonymous with premium craftsmanship and advanced preservation technology, ideal for serious home chefs. With craftsmanship made to last a minimum of 20 years, Sub-Zero refrigerators are considered the crème of the crème for a reason. Explore the full collection for state-of-the-art food preservation that’s worth every penny.
Featured Pick: Sub-Zero® Classic Series 42 in. 24.7 Cu. Ft. Stainless Steel Built In French Door Refrigerator
Shop This Sub-Zero Refrigerator
If you're looking for a fridge that represents luxury and performance, this Sub-Zero refrigerator is it. It's designed with durability in mind because Sub-Zero appliances are built to last. The cooling features are at the top of the class, with the Split Climate intelligent cooling system that precisely controls the temperature to keep food fresher longer. Plus, this unit caters to diverse storage needs with the adjustable door bins and a flip-up dairy compartment. The addition of Wi-Fi connectivity allows for remote monitoring, which is a good investment for a modern smart home.
Thermador Refrigerators
Thermador refrigerators combine high-end innovation with custom styling, delivering professional-grade performance and design. A leader in the premium class, these high-end refrigerators are the perfect addition to gourmet kitchens and a dream for serious cooks who cherish every ingredient.
Featured Pick: Thermador® Freedom® 42 in. 22.3 Cu. Ft. Stainless Steel Built In Counter Depth French Door Refrigerator
Shop This Thermador Refrigerator
This Thermador refrigerator combines luxury and innovation with various features that won't disappoint. Its ThermaFresh Pro system uses dual compressors and evaporators with Cool Air Flow Technology to maintain optimal temperature and humidity levels, guaranteeing the ultimate freshness. Equipped with the ThermaFlex Drawer with its own customizable settings, you can store various food items without worry. For maximum efficiency, it even has a redesigned shelving system that accommodates gallon-sized containers. We also appreciate the full-color touchscreen display for its intuitive control of the settings.
KitchenAid Refrigerators
KitchenAid refrigerators focus on culinary features for home cooks who love to the art of cooking. A mid-end brand, KitchenAid fridges are the sweet spot for buyers who want upgraded features and designs without stepping into the luxury class.
Featured Pick: KitchenAid® 36 in. 22.6 Cu. Ft. Stainless Steel with PrintShield™ Finish Counter-Depth Side-by-Side Refrigerator
Shop This KitchenAid Refrigerator
Looking for a reliable fridge with a counter-depth design? This KitchenAid model comes highly recommended for its elegant built-in look with a finish that resists fingerprints and smudges. It also comes with the Preserva Food Care Systems for optimal freshness, and the Measured Water Fill function provides precise water dispensing. You don't have to worry about shelf space as the interior makes sure there's ample room, such as with the In-Door-Ice system that frees up space—an efficient and convenient addition to your kitchen.
⭐Featured KitchenAid KRSC703HPS Review:
"Looks good, works well. Purchased counter depth since regular sized fridges stick out too much in the house we had just built. But counter depth results in storage shortage at a premium price."
Café Refrigerators
Blending high-end design with customizable finishes, Café refrigerators provide both beauty and smart technology for a personalized kitchen experience. As part of the GE appliance family, serving as the group’s deluxe line, you can expect useful upgrades and exclusive features, plus some of the industry’s most trending finishes such as matte white and matte black.
Featured Pick: Café™ 36 in. 28.7 Cu. Ft. Stainless Steel French Door Refrigerator
This fridge is built for a medium to large household with its spacious capacity that features a versatile convertible drawer with five customizable temperature settings. The dual-evaporator systems that provide optimal control over humidity and the dual-dispense AutoFill pitcher that automatically refills when placed on its docking station are highly convenient. If that's enough, you'll probably love its flatbread freezer compartment. This sleek fridge with unstoppable functionality and gorgeous aesthetics is a powerhouse.
⭐Featured Cafe CGE29DP2TS1 Review:
"The capacity of this refrigerator is exactly what I wanted. I love the exterior for ease of cleaning and NO fingerprints! The freezer with the multiple layers is brilliant! Now I just hope it lasts at least 10 years because it was not inexpensive!"
Why Trust Don’s Appliances?
Founded in 1971, Don’s Appliances is a family-owned, independent appliance retailer based out of Pittsburgh, PA. Don’s has since expanded to 10 locations selling, delivering, installing, and servicing all major appliance brands. Large enough to offer competitive pricing yet small enough to continue offering the “white glove” service we pride ourselves on, our focus is always on the customer experience — from the first step into a showroom to the purchase transaction to well after your new appliance has been installed.
When our customers are remodeling or building a new house, Don’s has all the expertise, product knowledge, inventory, brands, displays, and services to meet and exceed your needs. And in the event an appliance breaks, we are there, right on time and with the right product, delivery, installation, and service.
Shop Refrigerators at Don’s
Don’t put off until tomorrow what you can do today, and shop refrigerators online at Don’s Appliance. Our friendly experts are always happy to help you decide whether it’s time to repair or replace refrigerator models — whether you call us at 866-544-1711, email us, or use our online chat feature. Better yet, stop by any of our Don’s Appliances Pittsburgh, PA warehouse locations. Visit us today!
Learn More: High-End Refrigerator Buying Guide